Every new federal contractor hits the same wall: proposals want past performance, but how do you show it before your first federal win? The loop isn't actually closed — evaluators want relevant, documented work, not necessarily federal work. Here's what counts and how to present it.
You do not need federal experience to demonstrate past performance. Evaluators want work that is relevant and documented — which means commercial projects, state and local contracts, subcontracting under a prime, and your key personnel's prior experience can all count. Document each with scope, value, timeframe, outcome, and a reference — then build federal CPARS ratings on every contract you win.
The Past Performance Paradox
Every new federal contractor runs into the same wall: proposals ask for past performance, but how do you show federal past performance before you have won a federal contract? It feels like a closed loop — you need experience to win, and you need to win to get experience.
Here is the good news: the loop is not actually closed. Federal evaluators do not require that your past performance be federal. They require that it be relevant and documented. Commercial work, state and local contracts, subcontracting, and your team's prior experience can all count — if you present them correctly.
What Past Performance Actually Is
Past performance is the government's way of predicting future results. When evaluators assess it, they are asking a simple question: has this business (or its people) successfully done work like this before? The emphasis is on relevance — similar scope, size, and complexity — not on whether the prior work happened to be a federal contract.
This distinction is what opens the door for new contractors. A commercial project of comparable scope and complexity can be more persuasive than a small, unrelated federal contract.
Four Sources of Past Performance for New Contractors
1. Commercial Work
Your existing commercial clients are legitimate past performance. A private-sector project similar in scope to what the government is buying demonstrates you can deliver. Document the client, the scope, the dollar value, the timeframe, and the outcome — and secure a reference contact willing to speak to your performance.
2. State and Local Government Contracts
If you have done work for a state agency, county, city, or school district, that is government past performance — and it demonstrates you can operate in a public-sector environment with its reporting and compliance demands. It is often viewed as highly relevant to federal work.
3. Subcontracting Under a Prime
This is the fastest deliberate path to federal past performance. Working as a subcontractor on a federal contract gives you documented federal experience without having to win a prime contract first. Every subcontract engagement should be recorded as past performance for future prime proposals. See Prime vs. Subcontractor for how to pursue this.
4. Key Personnel Experience
Even if your company is new, your people may not be. The relevant experience of your key personnel — work they performed at previous employers — can often be cited to demonstrate capability. If your project manager ran similar contracts elsewhere, that experience strengthens your proposal.
New vendors would tell me they had “no past performance,” and it almost was never true. They had commercial projects, state contracts, or key staff with deep experience — they just did not know it counted, or did not document it well. The regulations specifically allow evaluators to consider relevant past performance regardless of whether it was federal, and a firm without a record is not supposed to be penalized for that alone. What actually hurt these vendors was not a lack of experience — it was failing to present the experience they had in a documented, relevant, verifiable way.
How to Document Past Performance
Presentation is where new contractors win or lose on this factor. For every project you cite, capture:
- Client/customer — who you did the work for
- Scope — what you did, described in terms relevant to the federal requirement
- Dollar value — the contract or project size
- Period of performance — when the work took place
- Outcome — quantified results (on time, under budget, measurable impact)
- Reference contact — someone who will confirm your performance if contacted
Build these into reusable past performance one-pagers you can tailor to each opportunity. This turns scattered project history into a ready proposal asset.
CPARS: Your Federal Performance Record Going Forward
Once you win and perform federal contracts, your performance is formally rated in CPARS (Contractor Performance Assessment Reporting System). These ratings become a permanent record that future contracting officers read when evaluating your proposals. This is why every federal contract — even a small first one — is a long-term investment: a strong CPARS rating compounds into easier wins down the road.
Ready to Take Your First Step?
Biz2Gov helps small businesses go from unregistered to pipeline-ready in 90 days. Founded by former DoD Contracting Officer Bruce Ayres, we provide hands-on implementation — not just advice.
Frequently Asked Questions